Our Menu
Happy Hour During the Week
Open For Carry Out and Delivery
Download Johnny Pizzas To-Go Menu
ButtonPizza, Wings and Everything in Between
You'll find all your favorites on the menu here at Johnny Pizzas & Pastaria! From our famous pizza to our delicious pasta dishes, we have it all! Give us a call at (262) 560-0066 to place your order. Our delivery charge is $5.00 and minimum delivery is $20. Get in touch with us to try some delectable food today!
PRICES & MENU ITEMS ARE SUBJECT TO CHANGE WITHOUT NOTICE.
*While we offer a gluten-free pizza crust, we are not a gluten-free kitchen. Cross-contamination could occur and our restaurant is unable to guarantee that this menu item can be completely free of allergens.
Join Us
Call us to learn more about our happy hour specials!
Menu
Breads
House-Made Marinara Side
Mozzarella + Garlic Bread + Marinara Side
Tomatoes + Fresh Basil + Garlic + Onion + Balsamic Glaze
Spinach + Tomato + Mozzarella + Garlic Bread
Alfredo, Marinara or Garlic Butter for Dipping
Add Any Pizza Topping +$1.00 each
Starters
Wonton Wrapped + House-Made Marinara
BBQ, Ranch or Honey Mustard.
House Ranch
Lemon + House-Made Marinara
Lemon + House-Made Marinara
House-Made Marinara
BBQ, Ranch or Marinara
House Ranch
House-Made Ranch or Ketchup
Wings
Sweet & Smoky BBQ, Buffalo, Sriracha Honey, or Garlic Parmesan
Dipping Sauce: Ranch, Blue Cheese, or Honey Mustard
Salads
Size Options
Side - Serves 1 ⁞ Small - Serves 2 to 3
Dressing Choices
Italian ⁞ House Ranch ⁞ French ⁞ Bleu Cheese ⁞ Honey Mustard ⁞ Caesar ⁞ Creamy Balsamic ⁞ Fat-Free Ranch ⁞ Fat-Free Italian ⁞ Oil & Vinegar
Iceberg + Spinach + Cucumbers + Tomatoes + Red Onion + Chini + Croutons
Chicken Breast + $4.00 ⁞ Shrimp + $6.00 ⁞ Bacon + $3.00 ⁞ Bleu Cheese Crumbles + $3.00
Romaine + Roasted Red Peppers + Black Olives + Red Onion + Pepperonchini + Mozzarella Slices + Italian Beef + Pepperoni + Giardiniera
Spinach + Mozzarella Balls + Tomatoes + Fresh Basil + Balsamic
Grilled or Blackened Chicken Breast + $4.00 ⁞ Shrimp + $6.00
Romaine Tossed With Caesar + Red Onion + Croutons
Chicken Breast + $4.00 ⁞ Shrimp + $6.00 ⁞ Anchovies + $4.00
Spinach + Black Olives + Roasted Red Peppers + Artichokes + Shredded Mozzarella + Cheese-Filled Tortellinis
Chilled Corkscrew Pasta + Broccoli + Tomatoes + Chicken + Ranch
Corkscrew Pasta + Black Olives + Tomatoes + Carrots + Italian
Soup
Sandwiches
Served a La Carte - Add Any of the Following Sides
Fries + $3.00
Onion Rings + $4.00
Italian Pasta Salad + $3.00
Side Salad + $4.00
Shaved Italian Beef + French Bread + Au Jus Side
Mozzarella + $2.00
Giardiniera + $1.00
Sweet Peppers + $2.00
Sauteed Mushrooms + $1.00
Try It on Garlic Bread + $1.00
Italian Beef + Sweet Peppers + Mozzarella + French Bread
Sausage Link + House-Made Marinara + French Bread
Beef Hotdog + Relish + Pickle + Mustard + Onions + Fries
Italian Beef + Sausage Link + Marinara + French Bread
House-Made Meatballs + Red Sauce + French Bread
Add Mozzarella + $2.00
Try It on Garlic Bread + $1.00
Lettuce + Tomato + Red Onion + Pickle Spear + Brioche Bun
Grilled ⁞ Italian ⁞ Blackened ⁞ Substitute Gluten-Free Bun + $3.00
Add Mozzarella + $2.00
Italian Chicken + House-Made Marinara + Mozzarella
Substitute Gluten-Free Bun + $3.00
1/3 lbs. Patty + American Cheese + Lettuce + Tomato + Red Onion + Pickle Spear + Brioche
Make It a Double + $4.00
Add Bacon + $3.00
Substitute Gluten-Free Bun + $3.00
Pastas
Marinara or Meat Sauce
Meatballs + $5.00
Sausage Link + $4.00
Marinara, Meat Sauce, Alfredo, or Creamy Tomato
Meatballs + $5.00
Sausage Link + $4.00
Chicken Breast + $4.00
Shrimp + $6.00
Capers + White Wine + Garlic + Lemon + Grilled Chicken + Angel Hair + Broccoli
Ground Beef or Cheese Filled +
Marinara, Meat Sauce or Alfredo
Lobster Filled Ravioli + Lemon Basil Cream Sauce
Garlic Olive Oil + Tomatoes + Fresh Basil + Angel Hair + Marinara
Mushrooms + Marsala Wine + Chicken + Angel Hair + Broccoli
Breaded Eggplant + Marinara + Mozzarella + Penne
Italian Chicken + Marinara + Mozzarella + Penne
White Cream Sauce + Penne + Chicken
Garlic Olive Oil + Broccoli + Penne + Parmesan
Chicken Breast + $4.00
Shrimp + $6.00
Sausage Link + $4.00
BYO Pizza
12" (Serves one to two) - $16.00
14" (Serves two to three) - $18.00
16" (Serves three to four) - $21.00
18" (Serves four to five) - $25.00
Traditional Thin
Double Dough + $3.00
Deep Dish + $4.00 (Allow Approximately 30 Minutes to Bake)
Gluten-Free (10” for Only $14.00)
12"
$2.00 per Item
$1.00 per 1/2 Item
14"
$2.00 per Item
$1.00 per 1/2 Item
16"
$3.00 per Item
$2.00 per 1/2 Item
18"
$3.00 per Item
$2.00 per 1/2 Item
Meat:
Italian Sausage / Bacon / Pepperoni / Ground Beef / Canadian Bacon / Chicken / Italian Beef / Anchovies
Veggies:
Mushroom / Onion / Tomato / Green Pepper / Black Olives / Green Olives / Broccoli / Roasted Red Peppers / Spinach
Gourmet:
Pineapple / Ricotta / Garlic / Jalapeño / Basil / Artichoke / Giardiniera / Banana Peppers / Fresh Mozzarella / Extra Cheese
Combo Pizzas
Sausage + Pepperoni + Bacon + Canadian Bacon + Ground Beef + Mushrooms + Black Olives + Green Olives + Onions + Green Peppers + Cheese
12" - $28.00
14" - $32.00
16" - $39.00
18" - $43.00
Garlic Olive Oil Base + Fresh & Shredded Mozzarella + Tomatoes + Fresh Basil
12" - $24.00
14" - $26.00
16" - $33.00
18" - $37.00
Mushroom + Onions + Green Peppers + Tomatoes + Mozzarella
12" - $24.00
14" - $26.00
16" - $33.00
18" - $37.00
BBQ Sauce Base + Chicken + Bacon + Onions + Jalapeños + Cheese
12" - $24.00
14" - $26.00
16" - $33.00
18" - $37.00
Sausage + Pepperoni + Mushroom + Onions + Green Peppers + Black Olives
12" - $28.00
14" - $30.00
16" - $36.00
18" - $40.00
Italian Beef + Giardiniera + Mozzarella
12" - $20.00
14" - $22.00
16" - $27.00
18" - $31.00
Bacon + Canadian Bacon + Sausage + Pepperoni + Ground Beef + Mozzarella
12" - $26.00
14" - $28.00
16" - $36.00
18" - $40.00
Garlic Olive Oil Base + Fresh Basil + Mozzarella
12" - $20.00
14" - $22.00
16" - $27.00
18" - $31.00
Calzone
Butter-Brushed Dough
Stuffed with Lotsa Mozza
Add Any Topping from Above +$2.00 each
Kids' Meal
Marinara, Meat Sauce, or Alfredo
Meatball +$2.50
Three Tenders + Fries
BBQ ⁞ Ranch ⁞ Honey Mustard
All Beef Dog + Poppy Seeded Bun + Fries
Four Fried Mac & Cheese Bites + Fries
French Bread + Red Sauce + Mozzarella
Dinners
Fries + Coleslaw Side
Coleslaw + Fries + Lemon + Cocktail Sauce
1/2 lbs. - $16.00
Full lbs. - $25.00
Six Tenders + Coleslaw + Fries
BBQ ⁞ Ranch ⁞ Honey Mustard
Desserts
Ask About Our Featured Dessert of the Moment
Drinks
Pepsi / Diet Pepsi / Cherry Pepsi / Starry / Diet Starry / Lemonade / Mountain Dew / Diet Mountain Dew / Dr. Pepper / Diet Dr. Pepper / Kiddie Cocktail
Try it Flavored +$0.50
Raspberry ⁞ Strawberry
Sprecher Root Beer / Lo-cal Root Beer / Orange Dream / San Pelligreno Sparkling Water
Cranberry / Orange / Apple
Regular or Decaf Coffee / Assorted Hot Tea
White / Chocolate
Fridays
Three Lightly Breaded Cod Fillets + Lemon + Coleslaw + Tartar + Choice of Side
Dill, Citrus & Butter Marinated Cod Fillets + Coleslaw + Choice of Side
Fries ⁞ Penne + Sauce ⁞ Italian Pasta Salad ⁞ Garlic Bread ⁞ Onion Rings +$4.00 ⁞ Side Salad +$4.00
Share On: